The following represents a departure from the safe space that our readers have come to expect from us on questions of sexuality and gender.
Dr. Ford of St. Tikhon’s Orthodox Theological Seminary submitted the following open letter for publication on November 7, 2017 in reply to Giacomo Sanfilippo’s “A Response to Ross Douthat’s Orthodox Admirer.” In his article Sanfilippo did not name the admirer or the seminary where he teaches.
In close consultation with an Orthodox licensed therapist the editors proposed to Dr. Ford a dialogical format for presenting his thoughts. This would have entailed an abridgement of his letter—which, at 5000 words, runs a full five times over our usual limit—and the interpolation of a paragraph or two of commentary from us at various intervals.
Two main considerations guided our proposal: first and foremost, the therapist’s concern for the potential harm to emotionally vulnerable LGBTQ readers of Dr. Ford’s unedited letter; and second, the fact that Dr. Ford does not actually engage with anything that we have published on the question of same-sex love.
Dr. Ford declined to proceed under the terms that we requested.
After sitting on his letter for nearly four months we have decided for a number of reasons to publish it exactly as written.
Our hope is that some benefit may accrue from adding this document to the conversation on sexual diversity in human nature and how it might reflect the image and likeness of God.
Addendum on 2/28/18: See Gregory Tucker’s response to Dr. Ford here.
My Response to a Response to a Facebook Post: An Open Letter of Brotherly Love to Giacomo Sanfilippo
by Dr. David C. Ford

November 8, 2017
Holy Archangel Michael and all the Angels
Dear Giacomo, fellow-struggler in Christ,
Glory to Jesus Christ!
I feel your pain, and I greatly appreciate your strong desire to help alleviate the pain that others are experiencing, as they try to find their way to inner peace in this era of much confusion concerning sexual issues. Read More