In Orthodoxy in Dialogue’s A Conversation on Theology, Church, and Life by Father Andrew Louth, and again in his Editorial in the current issue of The Wheel, he cautions that fear never makes a legitimate starting point from which to do theology. In the same vein, Archbishop Lazar notes that fear incapacitates us as Church to encounter the world “with confidence and grace.”
There is certainly a major shift in society, and it is very frightening to some people. Such shifts have gone on before in history, and they have always been frightening to a segment of the population.
For some years now we have watched the erosion of the kind of democracy that has developed in the West, based on the British system of parliamentary democracy. At the same time, we have watched the slow atrophy of religion in the West. There has also been a rise in right-wing authoritarianism, both political and religious.
We have seen this type of reactionism at other times in history, and we have learned little from it. Reactionism has never worked, and it has always compounded the social transformation that it was fighting against.
We should be able to encounter these shifts and changes in society with confidence and grace. Certainly, the Orthodox faith has the capacity to engage social transformations with dignity and peacefully. We must, however, be willing to accept that the past does not have all the answers. The past may be a foundation, but it is not a destination.
Fear incapacitates us and leaves us unable to encounter the realities of social change in any positive manner. Fear can drive us into a cold, unreasoning fundamentalism which does not allow us to draw from the real strength of the Orthodox faith to minister to society in a creative way which fully upholds the Gospel—the Gospel, not a religious ideology.
There must always be change, if for no other reason than the fact that we have acquired new knowledge and a greater understanding of our universe, our world, and humanity itself.
Fear can cause us to look for causes and cures in such debilitating constructs as racism, sexism, conspiracy theories, or even the demonization of refugees. Seeking simple solutions to complex problems can only help to create autocracies, authoritarianism, absolutism, and dictatorships, which ultimately seek to crush human aspirations and human freedoms. This takes place at the political and the religious level. Ultimately it betrays the very foundations and teachings of the faith itself—in our case, the teachings and life of Jesus Christ. We deify, or at least dogmatize, certain political and economic systems, but the Gospel does not have the answers to those questions: it is concerned with our spiritual life as distinct from worldly life. It does not deal with political and economic systems.
Nevertheless, there is a tendency to try to make a political or economic system into a dogma of the faith. It is easy to forget that the Orthodox Church once supported a system of autocracy and aristocracy that crushed ordinary people. That autocracy and aristocracy was replaced in the East by other forms of authoritarianism, and presently with an aristocracy which we now call an oligarchy.
The West has not been spared from the replacement of aristocracy with oligarchy and the degradation of the lower socioeconomic classes. We do not need to embrace this new aristocracy and the degradation of ordinary people as part of the faith. This is not what Christ died to initiate.
Archbishop Lazar (Puhalo) is a retired hierarch in the Orthodox Church in America (OCA) and founder of All Saints of North America Monastery in Dewdney BC, where he resides. In October 2017 the monastery organized the conference “A Sacramental Approach to Ecology,” co-hosted with the Department of Geography and Environment and the Department of Philosophy at Trinity Western University. See Archbishop Lazar’s interview “On the Neurobiology of Sin” and his June 18 letter to the editors in response to the border crisis at the US-Mexico border.
Orthodoxy in Dialogue seeks to promote the free exchange of ideas by offering a wide range of perspectives on an unlimited variety of topics. Our decision to publish implies neither our agreement nor disagreement with an author, in whole or in part.
Use our PayPal Button to support our work.
Click here if you would like to join our editorial team.
Check our Letters to the Editors and The Marketplace often.